Amesbury vs Merrimac

4BR house$25k apart
Amesbury$650k
Merrimac$675k
Both mid-range for Massachusetts towns
Tax billOn each town’s own median 4BR$900/yr apart
Amesbury$9,800
Merrimac$8,900
Both mid-range for Massachusetts towns
To BostonLevel
Amesbury73 min
Merrimac71 min
Both mid-range for Massachusetts towns
SchoolsMCAS percentile, statewide28 percentile points apart
Amesbury36th pct
Merrimac64th pct
Either side of the median for Massachusetts districts

marks the Massachusetts median on each scale. The better of the two is picked out where the gap is big enough to call; where neither is, they are level.

The prices are within about $25k of each other, so schools break the tie: Merrimac is ahead — 64th percentile on MCAS against 36th.

Amesbury

Choose Amesbury if you want the lower price.

All Amesbury numbers →
Merrimac

Choose Merrimac if you want the stronger schools of the two, or the commute matters most.

All Merrimac numbers →

Side by side

Some rows have no better. Town character describes a place rather than ranking it, and per-pupil spending tracks need rather than results, so neither is picked out.

SchoolsMerrimac ahead on 2 of 8
AmesburyMerrimac
School tiersolid schoolsT3solid schoolsT3
MCAS achievementState percentile, all grades36th64th
Student growthHow far the district moves children, not who enrolled46th48th
Graduation rate82.1%98.1%
State accountabilityDESE’s own summaryModerate progress toward targetsModerate progress toward targets
Spending per pupilHigher is not better — it tracks need, not results$23,135$20,723
Schools in the districtElementary and middle buildings the rating averages35
Private schools within 12 miAccredited, the fallback if the district does not fit11
What a home costsLevel across all 7
AmesburyMerrimac
4BR house$650kT2$675kT2
3BR townhouse$500k$520k
2BR condo$370k$385k
3BR homeZillow’s observed median, houses and condos together — measured, not modeled like the rows above$667k$670k
3BR rent$3,047/mo$3,047/mo
Income needed for the 4BRHousehold income at our standard assumptions$183k$186k
10-year price growthCompound, 2016–20266.8% a year6.3% a year
What you pay the townMerrimac ahead on 2 of 4
AmesburyMerrimac
Tax ratePer $1,000 of value — not what you pay$15.05T4$13.19T3
Est. tax bill on that 4BRRate times the town’s own median 4BR≈$9,800≈$8,900
Town spending per residentFY2025 general fund, per head$4,457$3,383
Share of budget on schools52%59%
Getting to workLevel across all 3
AmesburyMerrimac
Commute to BostonDoor to door at peak73 minT471 minT4
MBTA railNo MBTA railNo MBTA rail
Miles from downtown35 mi33 mi
Before kindergartenAmesbury ahead on 3 of 4
AmesburyMerrimac
Licensed child care programsBefore kindergarten154
Child care placesLicensed capacity, not vacancies61152
Centers vs family programsThe rest are programs in a provider’s home9 centers2 centers
Infant places in centersFamily programs report no age split1379
What the place is likeDescribes the two, does not rank them
AmesburyMerrimac
Population17,3666,723
Energy7/104/10
Compact center7/104/10
Family amenities6/103/10
Culture7/104/10
Gathering places8/106/10

The tax bill is each town’s own rate on its own median 4BR, so a lower rate does not always mean a lower bill. School tiers are editorial, shown beside the state’s own MCAS figures rather than derived from them.

Prices calibrated to Zillow ZHVI and Redfin · FY2026 residential tax rates · rail leg from the MBTA timetable, drive modeled · rents are HUD FY2027 Small Area FMRs · reviewed · methodology. Never uses demographics as an input.

Other comparisons

Amesbury vs West Newbury
$650k vs $950k for a 4BR
Groveland vs Merrimac
$750k vs $675k for a 4BR
Merrimac vs West Newbury
$675k vs $950k for a 4BR
Groveland vs West Newbury
$750k vs $950k for a 4BR
Newbury vs Newburyport
$900k vs $1.1M for a 4BR
Newburyport vs Salisbury
$1.1M vs $575k for a 4BR
Compare every town →